Our site, Destination-BBQ.com, is dedicated to covering all things SCBBQ. Use our interactive SC BBQ Trail Map to find restaurants near you. Keep up-to-date on News, Reviews, and Events. Try authentic SCBBQ Recipes for sauces, meats, hash, and sides. We've got you covered. Follow us on social media at the links below.
Reviews and Information on South Carolina BBQ, Restaurants, and Events
SCBBQ Restaurant Search
Follow UsClick Here to Subscribe
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Listen to this Destination: BBQ article.
It’s long been rumored that buzzard gizzards are the secret ingredient in the baked beans at Bucky’s BBQ in Greenville. In fact, owner Wayne Preston tells folks that is the unique spice that provides the special flavor he gets in his baked bean recipe.
We have looked long and hard for a source of buzzard gizzards, but I guess you have to buy them from some underground market. Knowing he couldn’t share his source, we were grateful that Preston would at least share the other ingredients in his baked beans recipe.
See Preston discuss the use of buzzard gizzards in this recipe:
Gizzards aside, this baked beans recipe from Bucky’s BBQ is, fortunately, a simple dish for the home cook to make. Preston starts with pre-cooked beans from a large can (55 oz) of Pork and Beans. Yep, it’s that easy.
Sure you can make your own from scratch, but frankly starting from dried beans is hardly worth the effort. What you add to those beans is where the magic happens.
Here’s what Preston had to say about the recipe:
“There are a hundred ways to make baked beans. Everybody’s grandmother has a different recipe. You can make them cheap or expensive, depending on how complex you want to get. This is a fairly simple yet very tasty recipe that I enjoy making for catering and groups that want a meaty bean that satisfies most anyone.”
It certainly seems to satisfy his customers. In fact, check out what some folks had to say about Bucky’s baked beans recipe on the review sites:
First, Michele D on Yelp wrote the following: “The baked beans were delicious; don’t know if they make them themselves or if they are out of a can, but they were great.” Funny, I know…
Also on Yelp, both Priya M and her husband tried this baked beans recipe and it was a hit: “My husband loved the mac and cheese and we both loved the sweet baked beans. This definitely hit the spot.”
Over on TripAdvisor, 1969TomT came pretty close to guessing one of the ingredients. “The other plate was ordered with sides of baked beans and slaw which were also very tasty, especially the beans cooked with a touch of cinnamon.” Cinnamon….allspice. Not bad, Tom.
Depending on how long you cook them, or if you choose to first drain off a bit of the liquid from the canned beans, Bucky’s baked beans recipe can provide you with a looser or thicker finish, as you can see in the Instagram post below.
However you decide to make your version of this baked beans recipe, we’re certain that you’ll enjoy it.
Let us know how yours came out by rating the recipe and/or commenting below.
Check out these other authentic SCBBQ recipes we’ve published on the site:
Please log in again. The login page will open in a new tab. After logging in you can close it and return to this page.